So Your Kid Wants to Be an Influencer?
Here’s How to Talk About the Real Paycheck
By Kathy Palmer / SmartPath Forward
Ask a room full of middle schoolers what they want to be when they grow up, and you’ll hear “doctor” and “pro athlete.” But you’ll almost certainly hear “YouTuber” or “influencer,” too. From the outside, it looks like the perfect job: be yourself, film from your bedroom, get paid.
If your child has floated this dream, don’t roll your eyes. It’s actually a great opening for a real conversation about money, work and how markets work. That’s exactly why we built our newest Family Finances lesson, So You Want to Be an Influencer? The Real Odds and the Real Paycheck.
Lots of dreamers, very few paychecks
The interest is real. In a 2023 Morning Consult survey, 57% of Gen Z said they’d like to become an influencer if given the chance. About 3 in 10 young people said they would even pay to become one.
The money is real, too, but it isn’t spread around. The creator economy was worth about $250 billion in 2023. Yet only about 4% of creators worldwide earn more than $100,000 a year, according to Goldman Sachs. Among creators who earn anything at all, nearly half make $15,000 or less.
For comparison, the median full-time U.S. worker earned $58,084 in 2023.
Economists have a name for this: a winner-take-all market. When roughly 50 million people are offering the same thing, the price for each one falls, and most of the money flows to a few people at the top. It’s the same pattern kids already see in pro sports and music.
One example from the lesson tends to stick with teens. A TikTok creator was paid $120 for a video with 10 million views. At about $200 per million views, earning a median paycheck from platform payouts alone would take nearly 800,000 views every single day.
It’s a business, not a hobby with a paycheck
Even successful creators describe a job that rarely stops. One creator with 1.4 million TikTok followers works from about 8 a.m. to midnight, seven days a week. Taking a break can hurt your reach with the algorithm.
And because creators are self-employed, the safety net that comes with a regular job is missing:
- Income rises and falls. One creator’s monthly pay collapsed even as his following grew to 2.9 million.
- The platform is the boss. Payout rules can change overnight. TikTok ended its $1 billion creator fund in 2023.
- No benefits. No employer health insurance, retirement match or paid time off.
- Taxes are on you. Once you net $400 in a year, you owe 15.3% self-employment tax, plus income tax, and no one withholds it.
The lesson’s interactive Creator Paycheck Calculator lets your family plug in views, brand deals and expenses to see what’s left. With its starting numbers, a creator brings in $7,120 for the year. After costs and self-employment tax, that’s about $3.86 an hour. That number tends to start a lively dinner-table debate.
Follow the money as a viewer, too
This lesson isn’t only for kids who want to be creators. It’s for every kid who watches them.
When a creator’s income depends on brand deals and affiliate links, money shapes what gets posted. Followers often feel they know a favorite creator personally, which researchers call parasocial trust. That trust makes it easier to sell to them. A University of Washington study followed influencers who mixed lifestyle content with sales pitches for essential oils falsely presented as cures for colds and viruses.
The lesson gives teens three simple questions to ask before they believe a post or buy a product:
- Is this an ad? Look for #ad, “paid partnership” or a discount code.
- Does this creator earn money if I buy?
- Would I trust this claim from a stranger?
Don’t crush the dream. Reframe it.
The goal isn’t to talk your kid out of making videos. Creating content can be a great hobby or side business, and it builds real skills: video editing, writing, design, marketing, negotiation and data analysis. Those pay off whether or not a video ever goes viral.
The trouble starts when content creation becomes a lottery ticket, and a teen skips school, a job or other skills to bet everything on going viral. The lesson helps families draw that line together.
Designed for parents and kids ages 12 and up to work through together in 45 to 60 minutes, the lesson includes:
- Real numbers on who earns what, and how creators get paid
- The Creator Paycheck Calculator
- Dinner-table discussion questions for teens, parents and everyone
- A “family creator plan” checklist covering school, taxes, privacy and safety
- Standards alignment for teachers, including Ohio’s Learning Standards for Financial Literacy
Start the conversation tonight
The next time your teen says they want to be an influencer, try asking: “If you posted every day for a year and earned $5,000, would it be worth it?” Then explore the answer together.
Try the free lesson: So You Want to Be an Influencer? The Real Odds and the Real Paycheck →
It’s the newest addition to SmartPath Family Finances, our free collection of lessons on budgeting, credit, car loans, teens and gambling and more, created by the Alpaugh Family Economics Center at the University of Cincinnati.